August 19, 2010

The Southwest Airlines Mom and How Our Society Condones Child Abuse


I'll admit that I get riled up pretty easily - but nothing, and I mean NOTHING, makes me more crazy than parents hitting their children in the name of discipline.  A story broke yesterday that has got me going.  A mother on a Southwest Airlines flight slapped her 13 month old child in the face and on the legs because she couldn't get the child to stop screaming.  Passengers complained, a heroic flight attendant intervened, and the child was taken from the mother for the remainder of the flight.  Ugh.  So sad, so maddening.

What really makes my blood boil, though, is that the police in the case let the mother go merrily on her way.  No arrest.  No jail.  Nothing.  I am outraged that our legal system and our society permit - no, condone - physical violence towards children, as long as that violence doesn't go "too far."

We've learned from this case that in our great nation, it's not "too far" to publicly slap your child in the face, speak to the child in a demeaning fashion ("Shut up" and "I didn't hit you that hard,"), and to "pop" said child whenever she won't stop screaming and kicking.  It's not even "too far" when said child was already sporting a black eye from an alleged dog bite.

There is an insane double standard at work in our country, as evidenced here.  If this mother had engaged in the very same behavior on the very same flight towards any other person on that plane (including someone else's child), the mother would have been hauled off in handcuffs and booked on assault charges.  Yet because she hit her own daughter, the behavior was a-okay.

Bang head on wall. 

The bottom line - our society values "parental rights" and privacy rights over the sanctity and safety of our children.  The only way to explain the insane double standard is that our society believes children are of less value than adults.  Since they are less than us, parents can do to children what they want, within reason.

It's tragic.  It's barbaric.  And it's blatantly wrong.

Listen up: The only difference between a child and an adult is the size of the body.  Children have the same minds, the same hearts, the same souls, the same fears, the same desire for love and respect and autonomy as adults.  If we are EVER to move ahead as a race, we have got to realize this.  They are not our property.  We do not own them.  We are their guardians, and that is it.

Spanking, "popping," slapping, shaming, all inflict harm on a child - physical and mental.  And if a parent is doing it, then he or she is not a guardian, but an abuser.

To the woman on the Southwest Airlines flight, to any parent that can not get between their anger/frustration and their raised palm or fist, I say this: Get your shit together.  Stop justifying your behavior as permissible because you're a parent, or because God or your church said it it okay, or because it was done to you and you're okay.  Get some therapy.  And learn how to control your freaking emotions.

Photo courtesy of VMJones, istockphoto.com

11 comments:

  1. i witnessed an incident like this in line a the grocery one time. the mother in front of me full-hand slapped her five year old in the face for jittering around and looking at the candy. another time near the fruit section i saw a mom slap her infant in his carseat. it was horrifying. i looked around though and everyone else was just pretending nothing happened. how is that behavior OK?!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I absolutely agree.
    And its infuriating that hitting a child in the name of love, or guidance, or discipline, is acceptable.
    But if an adult did that to another adult - in the same name - love, guidance, discipline - the law would intervene.
    It makes me sad for children.
    But its a sad sign of our society - and there isn't a simple solution.
    When people see someone hitting a child, the reaction is either one of anger & shame towards the parent (which results in more anger & shame directed towards the abused child, later), or ignoring. Neither is right. More teaching, more understanding...
    more access to alternatives to hitting for those parents who are interested in learning how to discipline without shaming or hurting, but don't have the tools (likely because they were raised by parents who also didn't have good parenting tools).

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you so much for educating people on the harm that child abuse causes. This survivor is delighted to have found this website!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Isn't is sad that this story breaks about the same time the other one does: the AZ mom who was kicked out of a McDonalds for breastfeeding her child? We let abusive parents off the hook and those who are gently nurturing their young get harassed. We still have a loooooong way to go, America.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I struggle soooo much with parents who choose corporal punishment of any kind to “discipline,” their children. The word “discipline” actually means “to teach.” What is a parent “teaching” their child by inflicting pain? As a teacher and parent of a toddler and newborn, I struggle with my patience often, but have had nothing but positive results by encouraging my toddler to use words, make smart choices, and redirecting when needed. She knows she is a valued and loved member of our family. As a society, we give kids too little credit. They are sponges, and learn best by our examples. A parent/caregiver needs to be their child’s champion and to teach with love and kindness.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I am confused as to why you say society condones this behavior. Child Protective Services would be more then happy to take a report of any of the incidents you mentioned above. Anybody can make a CPS report. Like Kelly said there is not a simple solution, but there are services out there to protect our children from the harm you mentioned. So please do not link everyone into "society" - I would find the majority of people do not hit their children. Unfortunately there are a few people who should have gotten a permit to have children.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anonymous, unless there are facts we did not know re: the SW Airlines Mom, the authorities did not do anything to this mother, including referring her to CPS. And, I would love to agree with you that the majority of people don't hit their children (wouldn't that be nice!) but as this recent article explains, 79% of them do. http://www.upi.com/Health_News/2010/08/10/Most-US-parents-spank-preschoolers/UPI-77641281419424/.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Au contraire, my friends! The hitting was NOT condoned. I am amazed and inspired by this story that the people around the mother and child spoke up and even more amazed that the flight attendant took the child away!! That is wonderful and inspiring! That the authorities didn't arrest the mother was probably a result of bureaucratic rules and all. Hopefully, somebody is calling DFS. Hugging and loving you for your advocacy and for who you are, Katherine! John

    ReplyDelete
  9. John, I am grateful that people spoke up on that flight too. That is wonderful :) And yes, I do hope DFS did eventually look into them.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I really agree with everything you said! I do wish the police had contacted Child Protective Services and more thoroughly investigated the lady. We are assuming that in public she is exercising some restraint, but are afraid the abuse is worse at home in private. I think it is risky, however, to jump to the conclusion that a family should be broken up because the mother slapped her kid. I don't see how jail will teach anyone anything about patience and love. In bad cases, which I assume CPS can justly decide, taking the kids away is the best option. But, if 79% of families are really doing this like you said, there aren't enough foster homes! I just think preserving and strengthening the families is the best idea, through education and awareness, all of that stuff you said!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I am so shocked that this mother wasn't at least interviewed by police on her arrival. Good on the staff and other travellers! I would love to have known what she said when her baby was removed from her!! Slapping a baby is unforgivable!!! OK ... slapping anyone is unforgivable but a baby?? She could give it brain damage, or snap it's neck !!

    I hold my hand up, I am a Brit, and a 56 yr old grandmother, retired and living in Portugal. Spanking was normal in my day - and it ruined my childhood and my relationship with my parents. But even way back then when I was a child, slapping a child around the face was really frowned on. Not to say it didn't happen - but it was pretty rare. Even my mother said it was rare in her day too - not AS rare though !!!

    I just dont' understand anyone who thinks hitting a defenceless child is either right - or achieves anything good !!

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts with Thumbnails